In a shocking incident that has left the Princeton community reeling, 31-year-old Matthew Hertgen, a former college soccer standout, has been arrested and charged with the brutal murder of his younger brother, 26-year-old Joseph Hertgen, and the family cat. The alleged attack, involving a knife and a golf club, occurred on February 22, 2025, in their shared apartment near the prestigious Princeton University campus.
The Incident
Authorities responded to a 911 call placed by Matthew, who reported a fire and a deceased individual at their residence in the upscale Michelle Mews apartment complex. Upon arrival, law enforcement discovered Joseph’s lifeless body, bearing significant blunt force trauma and lacerations. A subsequent search revealed the remains of the family’s cat, which had also been killed. Investigators believe that both a knife and a golf club were utilized in the assaults.
The Hertgen Brothers
The Hertgen family, well-known in Princeton’s affluent circles, has been described as embodying the “all-American” dream. Both Matthew and Joseph were celebrated athletes, with impressive academic and sports careers.
- Matthew Hertgen: A former soccer star at Wesleyan University, Matthew was recognized for his exceptional talent on the field. However, in the months leading up to the tragic event, he reportedly posted a violent poem on social media, hinting at underlying turmoil.
- Joseph Hertgen: The younger of the two, Joseph excelled both academically and athletically at the University of Michigan, where he was a standout soccer player. He had recently embarked on a promising career in asset management.
Community Reaction
The shocking nature of the crime has left the local community and those who knew the Hertgen family in a state of disbelief. Joseph Mahon, a former coach who mentored both brothers during their high school years, expressed his devastation:
“It’s unimaginable. They were both such talented and driven young men. This tragedy is beyond comprehension.”
Neighbors in the Michelle Mews complex, known for its proximity to Princeton University and its high-end accommodations, have also voiced their shock. Many described the Hertgen brothers as polite and reserved, with no prior indications of familial discord.
Legal Proceedings
Matthew Hertgen has been formally charged with first-degree murder, multiple weapons offenses, and animal cruelty. Under New Jersey law, a first-degree murder conviction carries a potential sentence of 30 years to life imprisonment.
During his initial court appearance, Matthew appeared disoriented and offered no plea. The presiding judge has ordered a comprehensive psychological evaluation to determine his mental state at the time of the alleged offenses.
Ongoing Investigation
While the primary suspect is in custody, investigators are diligently working to piece together the events leading up to the tragic incident. Authorities have appealed to the public for any information that might shed light on the brothers’ relationship or any potential motives behind the attack.
In the wake of the tragedy, the Princeton community has come together, holding vigils and memorials in honor of Joseph. Counseling services have been made available to students and residents grappling with the emotional aftermath of the incident.
Conclusion
The senseless loss of a promising young life and the arrest of his own brother have cast a somber shadow over Princeton. As the legal process unfolds, the community remains united in grief, seeking answers and hoping for healing in the face of an unfathomable family tragedy.
(Source : newsbreak.com )
