Fact-Checking Tommy Tuberville: No Proof of All-Trans Girls Teams in High School Sports

Fact-Checking Tommy Tuberville No Proof of All-Trans Girls Teams in High School Sports

U.S. Sen. Tommy Tuberville, a Republican from Alabama, recently made unverified claims that entire teams of transgender girls are participating in women’s high school sports.

Speaking on the “Megyn Kelly Show” on SiriusXM, Tuberville expressed his support for a bill aimed at banning transgender athletes from competing in women’s sports under Title IX.

Tuberville’s Assertions and Lack of Evidence

During the interview, Tuberville stated, “There are some high school teams in this country – in blue states – that are totally biological boys. It is a disgrace what’s going on.” He further argued that allowing transgender girls to compete would lead to the decline of women’s sports, as parents would withdraw their daughters due to safety concerns and discomfort in shared locker rooms.

When pressed by Kelly for specific examples, Tuberville claimed, “Most of them are track teams. You’re going to have a few in volleyball, you’re going to have a few in basketball. But mostly the track teams, and they’re in blue states. We get calls all the time about this.”

However, when AL.com contacted Tuberville’s office for evidence supporting these claims, his spokeswoman, Mallory Jaspers, could not provide examples of teams entirely composed of transgender athletes. Instead, she referenced cases where individual transgender girls won track events. “Sen. Tuberville was referring to the fact that he has heard stories from hundreds of women and girls who have lost trophies, scholarships, and opportunities to men,” Jaspers stated.

The Reality of Transgender Participation in High School Sports

Experts estimate that fewer than 100 transgender girls participate in high school sports nationwide, making it unlikely that entire teams of transgender athletes exist. Despite Tuberville’s assertions, no verified reports indicate that entire high school teams are exclusively made up of transgender girls.

The debate over transgender athletes in school sports has been a contentious topic in recent years, with many Republican lawmakers pushing for bans, arguing that transgender girls have physical advantages over their cisgender peers. Advocates for transgender inclusion counter that these policies are discriminatory and that transgender athletes should be allowed to compete in accordance with their gender identity.

Megyn Kelly’s Personal Anecdote

During the interview, Megyn Kelly shared a personal story, claiming that a private school in New York state had fired its athletic director because he opposed allowing transgender girls to compete. According to Kelly, the school allegedly planned to create an entire girls’ ice hockey team made up of biological boys to gain a competitive edge. However, she did not name the school or provide evidence to substantiate her claims.

Tuberville’s Legislative Push

Tuberville’s bill seeks to prohibit transgender athletes from competing in women’s sports under Title IX protections. He stated that while Republicans support the measure, Democratic votes are needed to overcome a Senate filibuster. Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D., has reportedly assured Tuberville that the bill will be brought to the Senate floor for debate.

“Now, it’s time to put up or shut up,” Tuberville said. “We’ve got to get it on the floor so people can see. If it’s not going to pass, we’ll do it again. But we’ve got to get people on the record because this is something that is very dear to the hearts of all parents across this country, and it’s dead wrong.”

Conclusion

Despite Tuberville’s claims, no verifiable evidence has been presented to suggest that entire high school sports teams are made up of transgender girls. The debate over transgender athletes in school sports continues to be highly divisive, with lawmakers, advocates, and parents taking strong stances on both sides of the issue. As the bill moves forward, its outcome will likely influence the future of transgender participation in high school athletics.

Disclaimer—Our team has checked this article to ensure its accuracy and eliminate any misinformation. We are committed to providing clear and reliable information for our readers.

Michael Bagwell

Michael Bagwell

Michael Bagwell is a US and tech news reporter with three years of experience, specializing in emerging technologies and their societal impact. He covers the latest trends, innovations, and policy changes for ManateeHSNews.com. Michael brings a deep understanding of tech to his reporting, offering clear insights for readers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *